#The Persian riding coats found in late Antiquity Egypt cannot be taken as 'typical Roman soldiers kit'
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Text
RE: cultural appropriation primarily being about an economic state of affairs where white people make money off of other people, a related idea I've been contemplating but haven't been able to like. Finish writing about is the idea of cultural decontextualization, which is when a cultural majority (often but not always white people) engage with another culture in a manner that erases- and may simultaneously replicate- racist histories, and is more about creating false narratives than economics.
A personal example would be white people making clothes based off of Coptic Egyptian artifacts, especially while generically referring to them as "Roman" or arguing Coptic art does not exist, which denies Copts part of Coptic history while resurrecting the French Coptomania of the 1920s, and specifically Albert Gayet's actions of taking items from Coptic graves to the point where a model was dressed in a tunic and shown off (which is also terrible from an artifact preservation perspective- this tunic would've been at minimum, 1300 years old at the time).
#cipher talk#Other examples are a lot of shit historical customers do#Like the Cathy Hay peacock dress debacle. Given that an Indian embroiderer faced heavy harassment it counts on both fronts#A lot of what Fr*da K*hlo did to my understanding also counts- both for CA and CD#Just going off what I've read from LatAm (for lack of a better word) Indigenous people have to say about her#There is also sometimes an economic element here#Like plenty of these replicas are sold#Plus it results in bad history#The Persian riding coats found in late Antiquity Egypt cannot be taken as 'typical Roman soldiers kit'#They're representative of a specific relationship Coptic Egypt had to Persia in late Antiquity#But I see drawings featured in academic sources misrepresenting this but shoeing a white Roman soldier in one at least a century before the#Evidence we have for them existing in Egypt#And plenty of white re-enactors claiming these are examples of fibulatron#They are not!!!
38 notes
·
View notes